WWII love letters hidden behind wall in New York home delivered to family 80 years later

It is said that true love stands the test of time.

For Carol Bohlin of Tinmouth, Vermont, it’s her parents’ World War II-era love letters that proved indelible when they were gifted to her by a complete stranger who found them nearly 80 years after they were written. 

“I was really so surprised they found these,” Bohlin, 76, told Fox News Digital. 

“In the letters, he was very concerned about my mother because she was not very well,” Bohlin said.

“He called her ‘dearest’ and ‘honey.’ He asked about relatives, like an uncle I never met who died of tuberculosis in his 20s,” she added. 

“He mentioned my grandparents, Willie and Ruth, and wanted to know how they were doing. So, that brought back a lot of things I had heard as a child. I met my grandfather, but he died when I was little,” Bohlin said.

In 1995, Dottie Kearney and her husband purchased Bohlin’s childhood home.

While they were doing some renovations, they discovered the handwritten letters behind a wall, according to Kearney.

‘Most precious love story’

The letters seemed to have fallen through a crack in the attic. 

After reading a few, Kearney said she immediately realized she’d found a treasure.

“It is the most precious love story,” Kearney told Fox News Digital. 

“You could tell she opened them with care and cherished them,” Kearney said.

“Everything was still intact. Nothing was smudged, nothing was discolored. They were pretty amazing.”

Kearney said she desperately wanted to return the letters to the family, but did not know how to track down the descendants of the couple.

“I couldn’t find any contact information, where I could send them or who they belonged to,” Kearney said. 

Claude and Marie Smythe are pictured above. The pair sent love letters back and forth to each other during World War II, when Claude Smythe was serving in the U.S. Navy. (MyHeritage.com)

“So I put a ribbon around them and kept them in my secretary for years,” she added.

“When we sold that house and moved, I brought the letters with me. I said, ‘One day I’m going to find out where these letters belong.’”

‘Wanted them to be found’

Twenty-eight years later, Kearney saw New York-based heirloom hunter Chelsey Brown, 30, on “The Kelly Clarkson Show.” 

She realized she might have found someone who could help her locate the rightful owner of the World War II love letters. 

“It’s like the love story you read about or see in a movie and wish you had.”— Dottie Kearney

Brown, a New York-based interior decorator, has a passion for reuniting historical artifacts with long-lost family members.

“The second I realized these were World War II letters, I knew I needed to help Dottie find the rightful descendants of the couple who wrote them,” Brown told Fox News Digital. 

Claude and Marie Smythe are photographed while sitting in a vehicle. The couple’s newly discovered love letters became the focus of a great deal of attention. (MyHeritage.com)

“I cannot take on every project people email me about because that would basically be impossible. But I always prioritize Holocaust and war projects,” she said.

Brown used her resources, including the MyHeritage.com database, to connect Kearney with one of Bohlin’s sons — and eventually with Bohlin herself.

“In the end, why did Carol’s parents hide those letters?” Brown said. 

“They wanted them to be found one day. Those letters were meant for Dottie [Kearney] to find.”

Brown added that she enjoys handling letters, especially when they were written during wartime, because they served as a lifeline between people who loved each other.

Claude and Marie Smythe are pictured above on their honeymoon. (MyHeritage.com)

“I connect with them because you’re reading firsthand accounts from people. You’re reading their thoughts, their feelings, their loves, their hates, their heartbreaks, their passion, their excitement. It’s so beautiful and moving.”

Bohlin said her parents’ letters confirmed what she remembers about their marriage.

“He called her ‘dearest’ and ‘honey.’ He asked about relatives, like an uncle I never met who died of tuberculosis in his 20s,” Carol Bohlin said of what her father wrote to her mother in letters from 80 years ago. (MyHeritage.com)

“They had a very good relationship,” Bohlin said. 

“They were happy with each other and they loved each other. My father was always concerned about my mother.”

“And, then when I came along, he was concerned about me. He was a policeman — and he was always concerned and cautious of everything and everyone. And I think that’s why I’m a little cautious of things, too.”

“In the end, why did Carol’s parents hide those letters?” said heirloom hunter Chelsey Brown said. “They wanted them to be found one day.” (MyHeritage.com)

Bohlin said that after receiving the package of letters from Kearney, she sat down with a friend and they read the letters together.

“Sometimes I laughed and then sometimes I cried. I felt like they were here again,” Bohlin said. 

“I miss my mom and I miss my dad. It was like they were here with me. And I will always have these letters.”

While texts and emails have all but replaced the art of the handwritten note, Bohlin said letter writing has not been lost in her.

“I still write letters,” Bohlin said. 

“My grandmother was a writer, too. It’s just the way I was brought up. It would be nice if people did keep writing.”

Gretchen Eichenberg is a contributing reporter for Fox News Digital.